Intersubjectivity Without Agreement
نویسنده
چکیده
In this paper, there is an attempt to construct the notion of interstijectivity as a process of a coorakztion of participants’ contributions in joint activity. This notion incorporates the dynamics of bothagreement anddisagreement. Iargue thata traditionaldejbitionof intersubjectivityasastate of overlap of individual unakstandings overemphasizes agreement and&-emphasizes disagreement among the participants in joint activity. It disregards disagreement at two levels: I) byfocusing only on integrative, consensus seeking, activities, in which disagreement among participants of joint activity often is viewed as only the initial point of the joint activity that has to be resolved by the final agreement (macro-level), and2) by considering disagreements as only nuisances or obstacles while focusing on integrative activities (micro-level). To illustrate how disagreement can constitute intersubjectivity at macroandmicro-levels, examples of children’sdevelopment of a classroom play are examined. Diversity andjlui&y of intersubjectivity will be &cussed.
منابع مشابه
The Annotation Conundrum
Without lengthy, iterative refinement of guidelines, and equally lengthy and iterative training of annotators, the level of inter-subjective agreement on simple tasks of phonetic, phonological, syntactic, semantic, and pragmatic annotation is shockingly low. This is a significant practical problem in speech and language technology, but it poses questions of interest to psychologists, philosophe...
متن کاملInter-rater reliability and convergent validity of F1000Prime peer review
Peer review is the backbone of modern science. F1000Prime is a post-publication peer review system of the biomedical literature (papers from medical and biological journals). This study is concerned with the inter-rater reliability and convergent validity of the peer recommendations formulated in the F1000Prime peer review system. The study is based on around 100,000 papers with recommendations...
متن کاملMirror Neurons and (Inter)subjectivity: Typological Evidence from East Asian Languages
Language is primarily constituted by action and interaction based on sensorimotor information. This paper demonstrates the nature of subjectivity and intersubjectivity through the neural mechanism and typological evidence of sentence-final particles from East Asian languages and extends to the discussion of the relationship between them. I propose that intersubjecivity is a kind of embedded or ...
متن کاملIntersubjectivity as a way of informing teaching design for a community of learners classroom
In this paper, I relate concepts from research (mainly psychological) on intersubjectivity to problems emerging in designing classroom learning environments by considering one of my undergraduate teacher education classrooms, which I designed to run according to an educational philosophy of `community of learnersa, and I consider the issues emerging from these e!orts. It seems that the notion o...
متن کامل